Movie review: ‘One Day’ spans two decades of annual romantic reunions
Loads of romantic melodramas in cinema have revolved around Feb. 14th, St. Valentine’s Day, but true to the appealingly quirky nature of its oddly matched young lovers, “One Day” takes its erratic romantic cues from July 15th, St. Swithin’s Day.
That’s the day which holds, according to British folklore, that if it rains it will then rain for the next 40 days; if the sun shines that day the weather will be beautiful for 40 days.
It’s a fitting metaphor for author David Nicholls’ offbeat romantic novel – and the screen adaptation he also penned – about two young people whose lives are tracked on that date over two decades. They are working class Yorkshire girl Emma Morley (Anne Hathaway) and upper-crust playboy Dexter Mayhew (Jim Sturgess of “Across the Universe”), who meet on college graduation day, July 15th, and form a platonic-romantic bond that will profoundly inform the next 20 years of their lives.
After Emma and Dex make an awkward, tipsy attempt at a one-night stand, they tentatively agree to remain friends, even though their backgrounds and aspirations couldn’t be more different.
Emma is an earnest lass from the provinces who yearns to do good work and make a difference in the world. As played by Hathaway in stringy hair, boho outfits and owlish, Harry Potter eyeglasses, she’s a plucky, sardonic and very smart Eliza Doolittle figure who is certain to transform from ugly duckling to radiant swan in due time.
Dexter, played by the likable Sturgess with a dash of roguish, rich-boy petulance and a saving dollop of good-hearted warmth, is a son of privilege who views the world as his playground and seems bound to break the hearts of his well-to-do parents – disapproving dad Steven (Ken Stott) and loving but gravely ill mum Alison (Patricia Clarkson).
As Emma takes a dead-end job waitressing at a Mexican restaurant and longs to become a teacher, and maybe even a writer, she and Dex dance around the obvious – that she fancies him but he’s too callow to reciprocate. As Dex rises to dubious fame as the obnoxious host of a late-night TV party show and sinks into an abyss of sex, drugs and rock ‘‘n’ roll, he and Emma remain friends – she perhaps the only sane and stable influence in his wastrel life.
The narrative checks in on the two each July 15th (with clever graphics cues) as their relationship evolves through stages of disgust and acceptance, estrangement and bonding, denial and inevitable love. The evolution of the relationship is suggestive of Stanley Donen’s 1967 “Two for the Road” which followed the ups and downs of Audrey Hepburn and Albert Finney’s rocky love affair.
Former Dogma 95 director Lone Scherfig (“Italian for Beginners,” “An Education”) employs jaunty cultural cues to keep things visually interesting. But Nicholls’ script points up the daunting problems of adapting a full-bodied, era-spanning novel into a primarily visual narrative. The leaps in time often feel like lurches, important incidents and key elements of character development fall to the cutting-room floor and the story ends up feeling elliptical.
Fans of the novel can fill in the blanks themselves, but those who haven’t absorbed the full measure of Emma and Dex’s journey on page might well sense the film as a sketchy postcard album of a love story in which too much happens off screen.
Even so, Hathaway and Sturgess are such deft and appealing performers, and they stir up such lovely, compelling chemistry that on the “One Day” when the story turns truly, stunningly heartbreaking, only the most literal-minded and hard-hearted cynics will fail to be touched.
- Dennis King
“One Day”
PG-13
1:48
3 stars
Starring: Anne Hathaway, Jim Sturgess, Ken Stott, Patricia Clarkson
(Sexual content, partial nudity, language, some violence and substance abuse)







